MINUTES OF THE SAN DIEGO PHRF HANDICAPPING BOARD MEETING
Monday August 11, 1997
Officers Present:
Jack Pinhero, Fleet Captain
Dave Babcock, Measurer/Scorer
Buzz Remde, Secretary
Ken Gust, Handicapper
John Wylie, Past Fleet Captain
Wayne Coulon, Roster Secretary
Dennis Conner, Treasurer
Area G Handicappers:
Larry Schmitz MBYC
Tom Seitz NYCYC
Michael McGinty CCYC
Chris Guild CYC
Dave Babcock SWYC
Mike Mickley SWYC
Ron Trotter CVYC
Fleet Members and guests present:
Name Boat Name
Dan Nolan PHRF
John Wylie Tobasco
Dan Harlan Miss Ali
Ian Trotter Thunderbox
Bob Steen Speedwagon
Chris Winnard Speedwagon
Dave Babock Speedwagon
Rick Sheldon Midnight Express
Peter Senft Midnight Express
John Dekker No Name Yet!
Dave Babcock
Drew Freides
Jim Eschwege Reliance
Tom Carruthers Invincible
1. The meeting was called to order at 7:07 pm. A quorum was noted. Officers and Guest were introduced.
2. July 14 Minutes were received and it was MSP to accept them as written.
HANDICAPPING
3. Old Business:
A. Second Readings:
Tabasco 28881, N./M 39, Provisional 24p/24p. Establishment of Buoy/RLC (Base) Rating: C.2.b, C.2.e and C2f part 2.
After discussion , MSP for establishing a new BUOY/RLC handicap of 24/24. Final discussion included reviewing race results from North Race Week (97) and the 1996 Championship Regatta Results, and supplemental IMS data. It was noted that this number was more inline with IMS data on Hi Five and IT's OK .
MSP requesting Regional to sustain this action
CF_27 (150/150 Area G) Second Reading Review for 147/147 Area Rating: Active boats: Midnight Express 57991 Nemesis, 67158
Discussion by skippers and board included review of data summary sheet: It was noted that no "written Invitation" as required was sent to the skippers, so all further discussion and voting was tabled until the September 97 meeting. Handicapper to send Second "Reading" Letters.
4. New Business: New Rating:
INVINCIBLE, temp s/n USA 30, N/M 29.
A package with MORC data, race results and other design information submitted by the owner was reviewed with discussion. MSP to start the N/M 29 at 87p/87p.
5. Other Actions: Follow-up on J-92 (Speedy Gonzolas s/n 46092) Asymmetrical Spinnakers
Summary: Skipper Bob Steen as directed had his asymmetrical Spinnakers measured by Ullman Sails. (See Table) Also submitted were:
1. A copy of Rating Application.
2. 1995 Rating Certificate for 46092.
3. 1996 Rating Certificate...
4. 1997 Rating Certificate...
5. Sail Order Form for North Spinnaker #1
6. Sail Measurement Certificate for Spinnaker #2
7. Letter from North Sails explaining the size discrepancies
8. Certificate from DR J, s/n 46192
9. A letter from Skipper requesting to be re-designated a J-92, not J-92 ODR.
Sq.Footage MFG. SLU SLE SF SMG DATE
J-92ODR 934 46.2 41.3 27.2 25.26
Speedy G
North #1 934 North 45.2 40.95 27.0 25.16 3/95
North #2 943 North 46.0 38.7 24.0 27.4 10/95
Banks Banks 45.63 38.77 27.2 27.93 2/97
Certificate 916 45.2 40.95 27.0 25.16 3/95
(all certificates and Rating Application Form has these same dimensions.)
Dr. J (46192)
ODR #1 934 Ullman 46.2 41.3 27.2 25.25
Current #2 1050 ? 46.25 39.5 28.0 29.75 (data on Certificate)
Actions Taken:
ALL J-92's
1. MSP to designate only CLASS LEGAL J-92's as J-92ODR (With small jibs and ODR Kites)
2. MSP to request Regional board to establish class standards as applicable for ODR vs. PHRF J-92's.
Speedy Gonzolas, s/n 46092
1. MSP to Sustain applicable reporting rules dealing with reporting requirements and Violation Penalties.
OFFICERS REPORTS
6. Fleet Captain- A. MIR issue, change verbage to allow any boat in any class to have the same sa the langest boat in that class.
B. Brought up Tobasco issue to Regional and will bring details to next meeting.
C. We eliminate the Big Boat Advisors. Set up committee of 3 specialists that will advise on handicapping issues.
7. Fleet Secretary- No Report
8. Roster Sec- No Report
9. Fleet Treasurer- Bal $3,128.67
10. Fleet Measurer/Scorer- A. Bay Series done and results passed out
B. No MIR for Area G Championships
C. Class breaks by boat type (funiture/performance)
D. Area G Championships will be under the Old Rules
11. Regional Handicapper- Regional is recommending to do away withthe non-spin offset.
12. Handicapper- Calender costs high and sugest we consolidate to 2 pages for next year.
OLD BUSINESS-
13. None
NEW BUSINESS:
14 None
15. Meeting Adjourned at 10:05 pm.