Minutes of the San Diego PHRF Handicapping Board Meeting

Monday, September 13, 1999

Officers Present
Wayne Coulon Fleet Captain
Steve Secor Fleet Roster Secretary
Chris Guild Fleet Treasurer
Al Poindexter Fleet Handicapper
Dave Babcock Fleet Measurer/Scorer
Mike McGinty Fleet Secretary
Past Fleet Captain
Ken Gust Data Systems Officer
Ian Trotter Handicapper-at-Large
Area G Handicappers
Present Brian Hull CCYC
Pete Senft CRA
Chris Guild CYC
Ron Trotter CVYC
Larry Schmitz MBYC
Marty McGee PLYC
Dan Harlan SDYC
SGYC
Michael Roach SWYC
NYCSD
Guests Present Name Club Boat Name
Geff Fisher CRA/PLYC Scrambled
Ian Trotter SDYC Thunderbox
Warren Gross MBYC X-treme
Bob Steen SWYC Speedy Gonzales
Don Prince CRA Blue Moon
John Rickard SDYC Spin Out

1. The Meeting was called to order at 7:11p.m. A quorum was noted. Officers and guests were introduced.

  1. The minutes of the August 9, 1999 meeting were distributed and approved.
  2. PHRF board meetings will continue to be held at SWYC until further notice.

Old Business

Fleet Business
Class Break Committee -

  1. The Performance Class 1 review committee met August 23. Meeting was lightly attended, but owners were well represented. Few ratings changes were recommended
  2. First Reading scheduled at PHRF meeting October 11, 1999 (SWYC at 7:00pm).
    Second Reading (if necessary) will be at PHRF meeting, November 8 (SWYC at 7:00pm).
  3. A letter will be sent notifying Performance Class 1 owners, including Scott Tempesta (new owner of Wahine).
  4. A note will be posted on the web site.
  5. It was noted that any rating changes would affect the Yachting Cup, and other regattas that are attended by out-of-area boats.

New Business

  1. Standard assignments
    Cat 30 Casamar (s/n 57789): No modifications. Assign established rating of 198. MSP
    Lancer 30 Seaduced (s/n 46831): Assign established rating of 204. MSP
    (Noted that rating is incorrect in database).
  2. Sport boats
    Mumm 30 Trouble Spot: Request by letter to be included in Performance Class 1. MSP
    Melges 30 (NAME?): Request by letter to be included in Performance Class 2. Not approved
  3. New application
    Sabre 34-2 Zandemere (no s/n): Rated 135-141 in similar conditions elsewhere. Recommended rating of 138. MSP
  4. Pending applications: boats wanting ratings for Ensenada race, prior to board approval. After discussion, it was moved that Handicapper Al Poindexter could "advise" of probable rating decision.
    Impulse 26 to Performance Class 3 at rating 132. MSP
    Andrews 58 cruiser Fantasia to Performance Class 1 at (-6 or -12?). MSP

Fleet Business

  1. Al Poindexter reported that he had attended PHRF SoCal meeting to present PHRF-San Diego letter of withdrawal. This was not well received, although SoCal may need a dues increase if San Diego withdrew. Withdrawal provisionally accepted, while good continuing relations among the entities were stressed. SoCal suggested we still plan to do 2001 Ch'ship regatta. Withdrawal of PHRF-SD is not a board decision, and must be submitted to the PHRF-SD membership for approval.
  2. SoCal scheduled First Reading for Soverel 33. PHRF-SD should also consider reviewing Soverel 33. If done, we should complementarily review Olson 30.
  3. New boat factors being considered, resulting new criteria used to establish ULDB numbers. ULDB number will be different on certificates.

 

Officers' Reports

  1. Captain:Wayne investigated membership in US Sailing. Need to submit application with $325 fee (based on # boats in fleet). Membership includes manuals, instructions, and guidance from US Sailing. Proposed to submit for year 2000. MSP
    Regatta liability insurance available for regattas sponsored by any member entity ($315/yr for $1m coverage). PHRF-SD does not per se sponsor regattas. This is done by area YC's. Care needed in wording of regatta announcements, esp. PHRF-SD Ch'ship regatta.
    Insurance premiums for officers and Directors are quoted individually.
    Budget committee needs to meet to discuss expense of separation.
  2. Secretary:No report.
  3. Roster Secretary:No report.
  4. Treasurer:Budget status report distributed. No expenses 2 months. (NB from Fl Capt: need to review 2000 budget plan as proposed fleet is ~270 boats @ $30 = ~$8,100 for operations).
  5. Handicapper:Need decision whether to do PHRF SoCal Ch'ship regatta in 2001. We will do and need to develop club sponsor(s) and (preferably) schedule feeder races.
  6. Measurer/Scorer:No Report.
  7. Data Systems:Ken distributed current fleet roster for review. Please report any corrections to KG.
    Ken distributed provisional bylaws. All to review proposed changes.
    Renewals: ask SoCal to print certificates & renewal applications. Forward all to PHRF-SD. Update our records first, then PHRF-SD will mail & return applications to SoCal. Possibility of splitting mailing costs.
  8. Past Captain:

Old Business

New Business

  1. PHRF-SD Ch'ship Regatta: worksheet of action items and sample SI's were distributed. Discussion of regatta format as one day/3 races. MSP
    RLC will be non-spinnaker only and 1 race only.
    Need to delete Sect 1B 5-race rule?
  2. Discussion of Bishop Rock Race. Time limit too long. Eliminate boats w/hdcp >162. Not a good venue for High-Point participation. Recommend to 2000 High-Point committee that BR be eliminated as a HP race. Committee formed to designate High Point races for 2000. Committee: Al Poindexter, Chair, with Marty McGee and Mike Roach.

Meeting adjourned at 10:30p.m.